We pit all seven apps against each other, reality game style, to see which app comes out on top. The answer may surprise you.
Note: We tested the iPhone versions of all seven apps.
Look and feel Letâs start with attraction. Except Yelp, the candidates are all good looking, with modern designs and big photos — Burpple is especially pretty. Yelp is the ugliest, with looks that date the iPhone 3G. Another appâs looks we are not fans of is SoShiok. SoShiok ticks the boxes but somehow it doesnât come together well. Like that person with too much plastic surgery: theoretically good looking, but really just weird-looking.
Good: Burpple, Foursquare, Pickat, 8 Days Eat
Bad: SoShiok, Yelp
Â Â SoShiok should look attractive, but somehow it doesn’t
User interface (UI) UI is like conversational skills; about how easy it is to get to know a person. There are two key things you’d want to know from a food app: what are the good places to eat, and is Place X a good place to eat? A great UI gets those answers as effectively as possible.
Yelp is the only app with an excellent UI in that respect. The candidate who came last in one episode comes first in the next. Hungrygowhere, Picket, 8 Days EatÂ and Foursquare try to do too much. For example, in Foursquare, check-ins and friend information interfere with recommendations â splitting the service makes sense from a UI perspective. Burpple has UI more like a news apps, which while fine isn’t as efficient, and SoShiok just seems confused.
Place recommendations If aesthetics is about looks and UI is about conversation, this is about character. How well do these apps actually recommend eateries? I compared each appâs overall review of places I know very, very well to see which are the most accurate. So itâs not scientific, too bad! We work with what we have.
Surprisingly, Foursquare gave decent results, in spite of not having mainstream adoption in Singapore. Unsurprisingly, so did Hungrygowhere and Yelp with their large base of reviewers. You might complain these two services can give bad recommendations, but thatâs like saying people can have a bad day.
Burpple is a funny case because it may not even provide recommendations per se. Burpple seems so bright and cheery â everything is awesome! â like that overly positive blonde cheerleader who gets on your nerves. For a restaurant to be above-average, another must necessarily be below-average, and Burpple fails to be a useful tool in that respect. The app does provide good ânearbyâ results, comparable to Yelp, Hungrygowhere and Foursquare.
Everything is recommended at Burpple
Pickat seems so commercial — recommendations are often accompanied with coupon offers. Hmmm. Pickat is the fake person you canât seem to trust.
SoShiok and 8 Days Eat give good recommendations, but only when you can actually find them. Their reviews arenât user generated, so there arenât many. These two are the kind at parties you donât know what to talk about with.
But of course Pickat’s recommendations come with a coupon /sarcasm
Editorial content Editorial content — e.g. food guides, top five lists, food news — this is probably the least important aspect of a good food app of the variables tested here, yet seems to be the biggest area of time spend for many. This isnât something international companies can easily provide, and accordingly Yelp and Foursquare offer little here.
Good: 8 Days Eat, SoShiok, Hungrygowhere, Burpple
Bad: Yelp, Foursquare
8 Days Eat put a lot of effort on food content… but does anyone care?
Conclusion Who downloads a food app just to read about food? Itâs a use case we donât think exists for the average person. Food content is still largely consumed with other types of content (e.g. newspapers and lifestyle magazines) than exclusively on their own (e.g. niche publications like Epicurious). Some of the apps in our face-off rely too much on users having a food porn fetish, when it should aim at being the best utility possible. A tool to get to whatâs needed as quickly as possible.
Tally everything up and we have an upset winner: itâs the ugly person with the best personality that wins. Yelp may appear drabby, but when it comes to the basics of letting you know what you should eat it stands on top. If only Yelp could get a makeover. Hungrygowhere puts on a little too much makeup and generally tries too hard, but otherwise is fine. Thereâs a lot of potential in Foursquare, who is coming-of-age and on the verge. Burpple is the hot person whose nice to look at but not actually talk to.Â 8 Days Eat merits a date or two. As for SoShiok and Pickat, itâs best not to pick up their calls.
Yelp could use a cosmetic makeover but remains the best overall food app
Disclosure: In addition to food blogs, my startup’s feecha appÂ features Yelp and Foursquare content. We do that because both have good, friendly APIs. Weâd feature the others too if they can get their act together.
The author,Â Jeffrey Yuwono, blogs at theÂ The Cornerplay, a weekly column about the tech and startup scene.
The views expressed here are of the author, and e27 may not necessarily subscribe to them
e27Â invites members from Asiaâs tech industry and startup community to share their honest opinions and expert knowledge with our readers. If you are interested to share your point of view, please send us an email to writers[at]e27[dot]co
Burpple is a smart and beautiful way to remember, organize and explore food moments with your friends around the world. Burpple is an app and website that helps you decide where to eat.
6M Series A Investors:
Tembusu PartnersQuest Ventures